Trump’s Cancellation of DACA Is Short-Sighted and Morally Reprehensible

President Donald Trump announced on Tuesday that he has cancelled DACA, the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program which has protected young people brought to this country as children, children who, before DACA, had been forced to live in the shadows without any protection against deportation.  The majority of these young people arrived as preschoolers, have grown up in the United States, know no other country, and speak English as their primary language.

I first learned about the need for a DREAM Act ten years ago from a guidance counselor who had been trying to assist the valedictorian at her high school with college admissions.  This counselor had learned that her state barred undocumented adolescents from qualifying for in-state tuition at its state universities and made such students ineligible for college scholarships.

Dale Russakoff profiled the issue again last January in the NY Times Magazine.  Explaining that even President Barack Obama’s DACA program—instituted by executive order in 2012—failed to address the educational obstacles facing undocumented adolescents across many states, Russakoff profiles a student in Georgia, who, “was determined to go to college and medical school and fulfill her parents’ interrupted dream. In her junior year (of high school), Indira began researching college options… She was distressed to discover that Georgia barred undocumented immigrants from attending its top public universities and charged them out-of-state tuition at all others—triple the rate for citizen residents. She then turned to researching financial aid and learned that Congress barred her from accessing federal Pell Grants, loans, scholarships, and work-study jobs—the most common forms of assistance for low-income students.”  After a long struggle, this young woman finally located a path to college in another state and qualified for some financial assistance from a private foundation.

The DREAM Act, (Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors), which would have assisted the 800,000 children, adolescents and young adults who were brought to this country as children by their parents, has never passed Congress.  While the DREAM Act was intended to guarantee access to higher education, President Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, DACA, provided at least minimal protection: the promise that registered participants would not be deported, the right to hold a job, and the possibility eventually of citizenship.

Earning DACA protection was not easy. In a statement released from Randi Weingarten on Tuesday, the American Federation of Teachers lists the requirements established by President Obama’s executive order for young people to qualify for DACA: have entered the United States before an adolescent’s 16th birthday; pass a stringent background check; meet educational or training criteria; and pay a $495 application fee.  AFT explains: “DACA status is not permanent; it is not a green card or a pathway to citizenship. It’s a temporary protective status renewable every two years. The average current age of DACA recipients is 26; the average age they came to the United States is 4 years old.”

When Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced on Tuesday that DACA will be phased out beginning March 5, 2018, he is quoted by the NY Times , which explains, “he was driven by a concern for ‘the millions of Americans victimized by this unfair system.’  Mr. Sessions said the program had ‘denied jobs to hundreds of thousands of Americans by allowing those same illegal aliens to take those jobs.'”

Economists, however, have been quick to counter Sessions’ argument that DREAMERS are stealing scarce jobs in the U.S. economy.  Here is Nobel Prize winning economist Paul Krugman: “Trump’s decision to kill DACA… is, first and foremost, a moral obscenity: throwing out 800,000 young people who are Americans in every way that matters, who have done nothing wrong, basically for racial reasons.  But it’s also worth noting that Jeff Sessions just tried to sell it with junk economics, claiming that the DREAMERS are taking American jobs.  No, they aren’t…. DACA is very much a boon to the rest of the U.S. population, and killing it will make everyone worse off.”  DREAMERS’ “educational and behavioral profile… doesn’t resemble the average immigrant, let alone the average undocumented immigrant; they look like H-1B visa holders, that is, skilled immigrants we have specifically allowed in because they help the economy.  Beyond that, DREAMERS are young—which means that they help the economy… because they mitigate the economic problems caused by an aging population…. (A)s the population ages, there are fewer working-age members contributing taxes to pay for Social Security and Medicare. A cohort of relatively high-wage, highly motivated people mostly in their 20s, likely to pay lots of taxes for decades, is exactly what the doctor ordered to make that issue less severe… So this… will make everyone worse off.  There is no upside whatever to this cruelty, unless you just want to have fewer people with brown skin and Hispanic surnames around. Which is, of course,what this is really all about.”

Opposition to passage of a DREAM Act represents narrow, fearful and selfish thinking. The idea that life in the United States is a cut-throat competition among our children—that if your kid gets a good education, she might edge mine out of entrance to a particular college or out of a job later in life—represents an extreme form of the ideology of individualism. Educational opportunity and the American Dream are not a zero sum game. People who oppose the DREAM Act also are likely to blame children for the so-called sins of their fathers. The leaders of our nation’s religious communities released a joint statement on Tuesday castigating Trump’s cancellation of DACA on the most basic moral grounds.

Senators Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Lindsey Graham (R-SC) have introduced a bipartisan DREAM Act 2017.  Please contact your U.S. Senators and your Congressional representative and ask them to support this bill, which would reinstate basic protection for DREAMERS from deportation.  The American Federation of Teachers invites you to use AFT’s action alert.

In a New Yorker satire, Eight Hundred Thousand People with Dreams to Be Deported by One with Delusions, Andy Borowitz captures the irony of the President’s stated reason for canceling DACA: “‘The people I am deporting are parasites who have exploited our economy,’ the man, who has declared bankruptcy six times, said.”

Advertisements